01-14-2018, 09:57 PM
I've read a couple of times that continuing to sharpen past a certain optimal point reduces the sharpness of a blade. This isn't something I've experienced with plane-blades or chisels, and my knife-sharpening skills are poor enough that I wouldn't notice (unless I measured a lot more often than I do). Anyhow, it doesn't make sense to me, so I'm hoping somebody can explain why that would happen. I can understand it if the sharpening is with a soft substrate, such as leather stropping, then it would make sense (and dubbing a perfectly good edge is something I've done all too often). But I don't understand how/why it would happen with stones, unless it's simply due to burr formation. I'm not disputing the claim, I simply don't understand the how/why. If anyone has an explanation I'd love to hear it, and if it's something other than burr-formation, I've very, very curious, indeed.

